Staten Island car accidents · served from our Brooklyn office
Staten Island Auto Accident Lawyers
Most Staten Island crashes are claims against another driver. A bridge authority or a crash on the New Jersey side of a bridge changes the rules.
Over 40 years of experience. Free consultation; no fee unless there is a recovery.

Where it happened
Where on Staten Island it happened, and whose rules apply
The location and the vehicles involved decide who you claim against and which deadline comes first.
- A local street or the Staten Island Expressway
- No-fault from the applicable insurer (DFS no-fault FAQ), and any injury claim against the at-fault driver and, depending on the facts, the owner; generally three years to sue.
- The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge
- Between drivers, the usual rules. The bridge is operated by MTA Bridges and Tunnels. An injury claim against the authority itself needs the claim presented, a notice of claim and suit within one year and 90 days (Public Authorities Law 569-a); death claims follow separate provisions.
- A bridge to New Jersey
- If the crash happened on the New Jersey side, New Jersey rules may govern. See our New Jersey auto accident page.
- A City-owned vehicle or a bus
- An injury claim against the City itself needs a notice of claim within 90 days; for a bus, the operator decides the rules. See our Staten Island bus accident page for transit.
The first month's paperwork
Keep dated copies of everything you send and proof it was received.
- Within 30 days
- Written notice of the accident to the applicable no-fault insurer.
- 45 days
- Proof of claim for medical services, within 45 days after the date each service is rendered.
- 90 days
- Proof of claim for lost earnings, within 90 days after the work loss is incurred, and for other necessary expenses, within 90 days after the services are rendered.
- If late
- Each of these limits applies unless written proof gives a clear and reasonable justification for the delay (11 NYCRR 65-1.1). Do not wait on that exception.
- Alongside
- A separate file on fault, injuries and any claim against whoever caused the crash. Our no-fault and PIP guide covers denials and medical exams.
Crash file
Building the Staten Island crash file
Crashes on the expressway and the bridges happen at speed and can involve several vehicles; crashes on Hylan Boulevard, Richmond Avenue or Victory Boulevard often have store and home cameras nearby. We collect the police report, vehicle photos, witness accounts and video, and identify any authority or out-of-state driver early.
- Police report number and whether the crash was on a bridge or approach.
- The other driver’s state of licence and insurer, if from out of state.
- Video from businesses, homes, buses and traffic cameras near the scene.
- Treatment records and work restrictions that connect the crash to the injury.
For where crashes are reported on Staten Island, the City's official map is Vision Zero View. We do not publish our own crash statistics.
Published results
Staten Island Auto Accident Results
None of the firm's published motor-vehicle results names Staten Island. These are the firm's results from across New York and New Jersey, quoted exactly as recorded, with the trial verdicts listed first.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts.
See the full verdicts and settlements archive$1,021,235
Million Dollar Verdict — Long Island Auto Accident
Plaintiff was involved in an auto accident in Long Island sustaining an exacerbation of prior neck and back injuries resulting in spinal surgery and physical therapy. Following careful deliberation, a Suffolk County jury awarded plaintiff a verdict for pain and suffering in the amount of $1,021,235 after a minimal $50,000 pre-trial offer.
Read the case study$650,000
$650,000 Verdict — Auto Accident with Injuries
The Licatesi Law Group obtained a $650,000 verdict for a 55 year-old woman who underwent discectomy after being rear-ended at a red light. The Defendant argued the accident was of minimal impact, and that the plaintiff had pre-existing conditions due to a previous spinal surgery. The last offer prior to trial was $12,500.
Read the case study$1,605,413
$1.6 Million Verdict — Plaintiff awarded after three-car collision suffering a spine injury
The injured plaintiff was struck from behind on the Hutchinson State Parkway sustaining injuries to the neck, back, and left shoulder. The plaintiff underwent a lumbar fusion and left shoulder surgery. After trial, plaintiff was awarded $1,605,413.39.
$1,025,000
$1,025,000 Verdict for car crash that led to two fusions of spine
The victim was driving on Route 112, in Medford, when he was stopped at a red traffic signal. His vehicle's rear end was struck by a trailing vehicle and sustained injuries to his neck and shoulder.
$250,000
$250,000 Settlement — Queens Parkway Rear-End Collision
After being rear-ended on a busy Queens parkway, our client suffered a torn shoulder and herniated discs in his lower back. His injuries disrupted his work and daily life, ultimately requiring surgery.
$800,000
$800,000 Settlement — Auto Accident with Severe Injuries
A hardworking individual's life changed dramatically after an accident at an intersection, leading to severe injuries that required spine surgery. Beyond the physical pain, the accident brought significant emotional and financial hardship.
Read the case study
Injured in a Staten Island auto accident?
Tell us where it happened, including which side of a bridge, and who was driving. We will tell you which rules and deadlines apply.
Deadlines
Deadlines that depend on who is responsible
There is no single deadline for a Staten Island crash. The first clock depends on who you are claiming against.
If you were injured
These are the first deadlines for an ordinary negligence claim for a non-fatal personal injury. Property-damage and other claims can run on different clocks.
- The other driver or vehicle owner (a private party)
- No notice of claim. A personal-injury lawsuit generally must be started within three years (CPLR 214(5)).
- The City of New York itself (for example, a City-owned vehicle)
- A notice of claim with the Comptroller within 90 days of the incident; a lawsuit within one year and 90 days (NYC Comptroller, GML 50-e).
- MTA Bridges and Tunnels itself (injury claim; the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge)
- Present the claim and wait 30 days, serve a notice of claim under GML 50-e, and sue within one year and 90 days of accrual (Public Authorities Law 569-a).
- The State of New York itself
- A negligence claim against the State goes to the Court of Claims: it must be filed and served on the Attorney General within 90 days after it accrues, or a notice of intention served within those 90 days and the claim then filed and served within two years (Court of Claims Act § 10(3)). A State worker or vehicle being involved does not by itself make the State liable.
If the crash caused a death
A wrongful death claim has its own clocks, which often start from the death or from the appointment of the estate's representative.
- Against a private driver or owner
- The estate's representative generally has two years after the death; if a criminal action is started against the same defendant for the same event, at least one year after that criminal action ends (EPTL 5-4.1).
- Against the City, a county, town or village
- Where a notice of claim is required, it is due within 90 days after the estate's representative is appointed (GML 50-e), and the lawsuit within two years after the death (GML 50-i).
- Against the State
- The claim must be filed and served within 90 days after the executor or administrator is appointed, or a notice of intention served in that time; in any event within two years after the death (Court of Claims Act § 10(2)).
- Against a transit or bridge authority
- Death claims follow separate notice and time-limit provisions, not the injury rules above. Identify the exact operator first.
2026 changes apply by commencement date. They cover personal-injury actions under New York's no-fault law (Insurance Law article 51) commenced on or after May 26, 2026; what matters is when the lawsuit is commenced, not the accident date (DFS Circular Letter No. 3 (2026)). For those actions:
- the former 90/180 serious-injury category no longer applies;
- a claimant whose culpable conduct is greater than that of the defendant, or of the defendants combined, is barred from recovery; otherwise, including at an even 50/50 split, damages are reduced by the claimant's share (CPLR 1411);
- except in an action for death, non-economic damages are limited to $100,000 for an injured person who is at fault, is not barred under CPLR 1411, and was operating an uninsured vehicle they were responsible for insuring (unless the lapse in coverage was less than 30 days), was operating while impaired and was convicted of that offense, or was operating in the commission of, or immediate flight from, a felony and was convicted of it (Insurance Law 5104(d)).
Court and office
Where a Staten Island case is filed
A New York action can be venued where a party lived when it was commenced or where a substantial part of the events happened (CPLR 503(a)). For a Staten Island crash that is usually the Supreme Court in Richmond County. A crash on the New Jersey side of the Goethals Bridge, Outerbridge Crossing or Bayonne Bridge may belong in New Jersey instead.
Staten Island is served from our Brooklyn office at 3857 Kings Highway, #1f, Brooklyn, NY 11234, (718) 710-4880. See Staten Island locations, the Brooklyn office and our Staten Island personal injury page.

Questions
Staten Island Auto Accident FAQs
Answers to common questions about Staten Island auto accident cases. For the threshold in depth, read the serious injury threshold explained.
No-fault pays eligible medical bills and part of lost earnings, up to $50,000 of basic economic loss per person, without first proving who caused the crash. A driver or passenger claims against the insurer of the vehicle they were in; a pedestrian against the insurer of the vehicle that struck them. Unknown or uninsured vehicles follow household-policy and MVAIC rules. No-fault does not pay pain and suffering. A crash in New Jersey can follow different rules.
Staten Island is crossed by the Staten Island Expressway and linked to Brooklyn by the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge and to New Jersey by three bridges, so a crash can involve a bridge authority, an out-of-state driver or a New Jersey location. Most crashes on Hylan Boulevard, Richmond Avenue or local streets are ordinary claims against a driver. A Staten Island case can be brought in Richmond County when a party lives there or a substantial part of the events happened there.
You can sue the at-fault driver, and in some cases the owner, for economic loss beyond basic no-fault benefits and for property damage. For pain and suffering you generally need a 'serious injury' under Insurance Law 5102(d). For actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026, the former 90/180 category no longer applies; the date the lawsuit is commenced, not the crash date, decides which rules apply. An injury lawsuit against a private driver generally must be started within three years.
Move to safety and call 911. Only if you can do it from a safe place, photograph the vehicles, plates and damage and note the lane and nearest exit or sign; never walk into or back into traffic. Get witness contacts, and do not argue about fault. Get medical care, for example at Staten Island University Hospital or Richmond University Medical Center, and keep every record. Give written notice to the applicable no-fault insurer within 30 days, then call us.
For actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026, a serious injury means death; dismemberment; significant disfigurement; a fracture; loss of a fetus; permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system; permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member; or significant limitation of use of a body function or system (Insurance Law 5102(d)). The former 90/180 category is historical context for actions commenced before that date.
It depends on fault, the injuries and their proof, and the insurance available; we do not quote ranges. A claim against the at-fault driver can add excess economic loss, property damage and, with a serious injury, pain and suffering. In personal-injury actions under the no-fault law (Insurance Law article 51) commenced on or after May 26, 2026, a claimant more at fault than the defendants is barred, and specified at-fault claimants face a $100,000 non-economic cap, with statutory exceptions including death.
You can file a no-fault claim yourself. A lawyer helps when injuries are serious, fault is disputed, the crash was on a bridge or in New Jersey, or a public body may be responsible and a notice is due. We gather the police report and video, track every deadline, assess the serious-injury question and file suit in the right county. Staten Island is served from our Brooklyn office. The consultation is free, and there is no fee unless there is a recovery.
No-fault benefits move on their own claim process. A claim against the at-fault driver usually cannot be valued until treatment shows the long-term picture; if a lawsuit is needed in Richmond County, discovery and court conferences add time. Disputed fault, several defendants or surgery make a case longer. Timing is decided case by case; settling before future care and lost earnings can be estimated can leave costs uncovered, and we do not promise a timetable.
A crash between drivers on the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge follows the usual rules: no-fault from the applicable insurer, and any claim against the at-fault driver and, depending on the facts, the owner. The bridge is operated by MTA Bridges and Tunnels. For an injury claim against the authority itself, its statute requires presenting the claim, a notice of claim, and suit within one year and 90 days (Public Authorities Law 569-a); death claims follow separate provisions.
We do not rank roads without data. New York City publishes crash and injury maps through Vision Zero View, which show where crashes are reported. For your case, the road matters for evidence and for who may be responsible: the Staten Island Expressway and the bridges have different records and operators than Hylan Boulevard, Richmond Avenue or Victory Boulevard. We try to request footage and records early, because they can be overwritten.
Serving all Staten Island neighborhoods
We represent people hurt in car crashes throughout Richmond County, including:
- St. George
- Tompkinsville
- Stapleton
- Clifton
- Rosebank
- Arrochar
- South Beach
- Midland Beach
- New Dorp
- Oakwood
- Bay Terrace
- Great Kills
- Eltingville
- Annadale
- Huguenot
- Prince's Bay
- Pleasant Plains
- Tottenville
- Charleston
- Rossville
- Woodrow
- Richmond Valley
- Port Richmond
- West Brighton
- New Brighton
- Grymes Hill
- Silver Lake
- Castleton Corners
- Westerleigh
- Willowbrook
- Bulls Head
- Heartland Village
- Todt Hill
- Emerson Hill
- Lighthouse Hill
- Richmondtown
Staten Island auto accident? Find out whose rules apply
We review where it happened, who was driving and every policy that may apply. Free consultation; no fee unless there is a recovery.
What to bring
- Police report number and the exact location or bridge
- The other driver’s insurance and state of licence
- Your no-fault claim number and any denial letters
- Medical records and missed-work notes
Related
Other car and auto accident guides
- New York auto accident claims: which coverage may pay
- Car accident lawsuits: fault and serious injury
- Brooklyn auto accident lawyer
- No-fault and auto accident help near you
- Find our nearest office after a car crash
- Staten Island pedestrian accidents
- Staten Island bus accidents
- Staten Island truck accidents
- Staten Island wrongful death
- Staten Island personal injury
- Queens auto accidents
- Bronx auto accidents
- Manhattan auto accidents
- Long Island auto accidents
- Our Brooklyn office
- NY no-fault and PIP benefits guide
- The serious injury threshold explained
- Nassau County car accident lawyer
- New Jersey auto accident claims
- All verdicts and settlements
Photo credits: Staten Island Expressway from the Hylan Boulevard overpass by Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped and resized.
