Skip to main content

Nassau County work injuries

Workers Comp Attorney Nassau County: When You Can Sue Beyond Workers Compensation

A Nassau County work injury may involve both workers' compensation benefits and a separate lawsuit if someone outside your employer helped cause the accident. Here is how the two paths fit together and why each has its own deadlines.

By Michael A. Licatesi · Published · Updated

(516) 227-2662
A tower crane jib with its hook block hanging against a cloudy blue sky.

Short answer

  • Workers' compensation pays for workplace injuries without proving fault, with narrow exceptions such as an injury caused solely by intoxication.
  • In exchange, workers' compensation is generally your only remedy against your own employer.
  • You may also sue a third party other than your employer or a co-worker, such as a property owner, general contractor or equipment maker, without giving up compensation benefits. The comp carrier generally has a lien on that recovery.
  • For an accident, generally give your employer written notice within 30 days and file the compensation claim within two years. Occupational diseases follow different timing rules, and statutory exceptions can matter.

This guide explains general New York rules. It is not legal advice about a specific injury.

What workers' compensation covers in New York

Under Workers' Compensation Law 10, employers must secure compensation for injuries arising out of and in the course of employment "without regard to fault as a cause of the injury," except where the injury was solely caused by the employee's intoxication from alcohol or a controlled substance while on duty, or by the employee's willful intention to injure or kill themselves or another. Benefits typically include medical treatment and partial wage replacement while you cannot work.

Why you usually cannot sue your employer

Workers' Compensation Law 11 makes the employer's compensation liability "exclusive and in place of any other liability whatsoever" to the injured employee for that injury, with limited exceptions, such as an employer that fails to secure compensation coverage. Section 11 also generally prevents a third party that is sued from shifting the claim back to the employer, unless the worker suffered a "grave injury" from the statute's short list of catastrophic injuries or the employer expressly agreed to contribution or indemnification in a written contract entered into before the accident.

When you may have a separate lawsuit

If someone other than your employer or a co-worker contributed to the injury, Workers' Compensation Law 29 says an injured employee "need not elect" between compensation and a lawsuit against that third party. You can receive benefits and pursue the third party, but the compensation carrier generally has a lien on the proceeds of any recovery, after deduction of reasonable litigation expenses including attorney's fees. A settlement for less than the compensation payable generally requires the carrier's written approval or a court order. Section 29 also makes compensation the exclusive remedy when the injury was caused by someone "in the same employ," so a co-worker generally cannot be sued.

  • Property owner or general contractor

    Example A fall from a ladder or scaffold during construction, renovation or repair work

  • Subcontractor

    Example A different trade left an unprotected opening or debris that caused the injury

  • Equipment manufacturer

    Example A machine or tool failed because of a defect

  • Driver

    Example A delivery or service worker was hit by another vehicle while on the job

  • Property or maintenance company

    Example A worker visiting another business slipped on an unsafe condition there

Construction falls and the Labor Law

Construction workers in Nassau County and across New York may also have claims against owners and contractors under the Labor Law. Labor Law 240 requires contractors and owners to provide scaffolding, hoists, ladders and other devices giving proper protection to workers doing covered work on a building or structure, and Labor Law 241 imposes safety requirements for construction, demolition and excavation. Both exclude owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work. Labor Law 200 sets a general duty to keep workplaces reasonably safe.

The difference matters. Courts describe Labor Law 240(1) as imposing "a nondelegable duty, and absolute liability for injuries proximately caused by the failure to provide appropriate safety devices to workers who are subject to elevation-related risks," while Labor Law 200 "codifies the common-law duty" to maintain a safe work site, so a Labor Law 200 claim requires proof of negligence (James v Marini Homes, 3d Dept 2025).

A worker wearing a fall-arrest harness guides a roof truss being lifted into place on a wood-frame house.

Whether a particular accident is covered depends on the work, the device and the facts. Our construction accident page explains more.

Step 1

Report the injury and get care

Get medical care and tell the doctor it happened at work. Give your employer written notice: for an accident, Workers' Compensation Law 18 generally requires notice within thirty days. The Workers' Compensation Board can excuse late notice in some circumstances, but do not rely on that.

Step 2

Save evidence for both claims

  • The incident report and the names of witnesses
  • Photos of the work area and equipment, when it is safe and allowed
  • Who controlled the site, which contractors were present and who owned any equipment involved
  • Medical paperwork and communications with your employer and the carrier

A third-party claim depends on details that compensation paperwork may not capture, such as which contractor created the hazard or what equipment failed.

Step 3

Watch both sets of deadlines

For an accident, a compensation claim generally must be filed within two years after the accident, or after death, under Workers' Compensation Law 28. Occupational disease claims are timed differently under the statute. Most third-party injury lawsuits must be filed within three years under CPLR 214, and claims against a town, county or other public body generally require a notice of claim within 90 days. See how to sue a city or public agency.

When to talk to a lawyer

Speak with a lawyer if the injury is serious, benefits are delayed or disputed, or someone outside your employer may have contributed to the accident, and before you sign any settlement. A lawyer can review both paths so the compensation claim does not hide a larger third-party case. Our Nassau County work accident page explains how we handle these cases.

Frequently asked questions

Sources

  1. N.Y. Workers' Compensation Law 10
  2. N.Y. Workers' Compensation Law 11
  3. N.Y. Workers' Compensation Law 18
  4. N.Y. Workers' Compensation Law 28
  5. N.Y. Workers' Compensation Law 29
  6. N.Y. Labor Law 200
  7. N.Y. Labor Law 240
  8. N.Y. Labor Law 241
  9. N.Y. CPLR 214
  10. James v Marini Homes, LLC, 234 AD3d 1078 (3d Dept 2025)

Hurt at work in Nassau County?

We can review both the compensation claim and any third-party case. The consultation is free.

(516) 227-2662

Photo credits: Tower crane (cropped, resized, converted to WebP) by ProjectManhattan, CC BY-SA 3.0, cropped and resized.